Moses was high on drugs: Israeli researcher
David Hobby
hobbyd at newpaltz.edu
Thu Mar 6 17:59:25 PST 2008
William T Goodall wrote:
...
>>> A drug induced hallucination is a real experience that doesn't
>>> correspond to objectively real events.
>> William--
>>
>> As many people were trying to point out to you,
>> that's not something you can prove.
>
> You do not actually believe that.
William--
No, I think I DO believe that it is impossible to
prove that there are no "other planes of reality",
or whatever we're calling them. And who are you
to tell me what I believe?!
>> You're the one here who's claiming certain knowledge
>> of things that are unknowable.
>
> You entirely mistake my epistemology. You are the one claiming that if
> we don't know something certainly we don't know it at all yet you act
> as though you are quite satisfied with the less than perfect proof
> that reality is just what it seems and we are not brains in jars.
> Clearly we do know things quite satisfactorily well despite not
> knowing them with complete certainty.
>
> Outside of mathematics and logic 'proof' means 'beyond reasonable
> doubt' not certainty.
I sense a circularity here. I bet you're going to define "reasonable"
so it explicitly excludes belief in anything outside this world.
I maintain that it is perfectly reasonable to doubt that what you
think of as reality is all there is. (It may not be USEFUL to doubt
this, but that's a different issue.)
---David
By the way, shouldn't you be consistent, and argue that we DO
know some things, since you are trying to PROVE that there are
no other planes of reality?
More information about the Brin-l
mailing list